Community Organization & Governance

1. Forming a Group

Optimal Group Size — What the Research Shows

Group size is not arbitrary — it has profound effects on trust, communication overhead, decision speed, and social cohesion. The research converges on natural size thresholds:

2. Critical Roles Every Group Needs

Assign these roles on Day One. One person can hold multiple roles in small groups. Write down the current role holder and at least one backup for each.

3. Vetting Strangers — Trust-Building Protocol

The Fundamental Tension

Two real facts exist simultaneously: (1) Every group of survivors needs more skilled people; (2) A bad actor inside the perimeter is more dangerous than 10 outside it. Your vetting protocol must balance genuine hospitality with reasonable security. Blanket refusal of all strangers is short-sighted; blanket acceptance is reckless.

Arrival Protocol

1. Initial contact at distance — have one greeter with visual backup (security not visible to newcomer). Observe clothing, body language, direction of approach, who/what is behind them. They may be a scout.
2. Brief interview outside perimeter — name, where they came from, who they were with, what happened. Note inconsistencies in the story. Offer water (observe how they handle it — is it for themselves or children first?). Listen more than you talk.
3. Decision: turn away, observe hold, or provisional admission — turn away if obvious threat indicators; put into observe hold (separate shelter, no internal access) for 24–72 hours minimum; provisional admission with escort for assessed low-risk individuals with strong skills.
4. Observe hold — separate from main group. Provide food and water. Rotate who interacts with them — inconsistency in stories emerges over time. Observe how they treat the animals, children, and lower-status group members.
5. Probationary membership — if admitted after observe hold, 30-day probationary period with no access to supply storage, weapons cache, or sensitive group information (secondary location, radio codes, route plans).
6. Full membership — full council vote after probationary period. No single person can grant full membership.

Information Compartmentalization

• Tier 1 (public knowledge): That you exist, approximate location, willingness to trade
• Tier 2 (provisional member access): Internal rules, basic resource levels, daily schedule
• Tier 3 (full member only): Secondary locations, supply quantities, radio frequencies, security patrol schedule, defense capabilities
• Rule: never reveal Tier 3 to anyone who hasn't completed probation. Ever. The information doesn't become safe just because you like someone.

Non-Negotiable Day-One Rules

Write these down and have everyone sign or thumb-print them within 24 hours of group formation:

1. No violence against group members. Any physical assault (except in self-defense against immediate attack) triggers mandatory council review with exile as the possible outcome.
2. No theft from group stores. Discovery triggers mandatory council review. Second offense = exile.
3. No rape or sexual assault. Exile on first finding. No exceptions, no probation.
4. No unilateral decisions that affect the whole group. Any action with group-wide consequences requires council notification before execution if time allows, or immediate reporting if not.
5. Everyone contributes to essential work. No exceptions for status, age (within reason), or prior social position. Work assignments are posted and tracked.
6. Medical resources are allocated by medical officer, not by social position. The medic's triage decisions are final in medical emergencies.
7. Truth-telling. Deliberate deception of the group on matters affecting security, health, or resources is grounds for exile review.
8. Security protocol compliance. Security lead's decisions during a threat are immediate orders, not suggestions.
9. Child protection. All children are under community protection regardless of parentage.
10. No hoarding. Private stores must be declared to logistics; exception: a personal small reserve (defined by council) is permitted.

4. Governance Models

Scaling by Group Size

Historical Models Worth Studying

5. Warning Signs of Emerging Tyranny

Groups that survive the initial crisis often fail 6–18 months later when a capable, charismatic leader consolidates power. Recognize these patterns early — they become nearly impossible to reverse after 6 months of entrenchment.

Recall & Removal Mechanisms

Write these procedures into your charter BEFORE you need them:

1. Petition: Any member can initiate a recall petition. Petition requires 20% of full members to sign to trigger a review hearing.
2. Review hearing: Conducted by all council members except the subject. Subject presents their case. Witnesses may speak. Confidential vote.
3. Removal threshold: 2/3 supermajority of council removes from role. Role reverts to interim appointment or new election.
4. Emergency removal: If council determines an active, imminent threat from leader, temporary suspension pending full hearing — by unanimous vote of remaining council members.
5. Succession procedure: Immediately after removal, the remaining council appoints an interim role-holder using established succession order (written in charter).

6. Laws & Justice

Conflict Resolution — Mediation Before Judgment

Most disputes can be resolved without formal judgment. Reserve the formal process for failures of mediation. Sequence:

1. Direct resolution — parties attempt to resolve themselves within 24 hours
2. Mediation — neutral third party (not in dispute, not a close ally of either party) facilitates a structured conversation: each party states their position; mediator restates it back; parties identify shared interests; propose solutions; agree or not
3. Council review — if mediation fails, council hears the case within 3 days. Both parties present. Witnesses may speak. Council deliberates privately. Renders a decision with written reasoning.
4. Appeal — one appeal permitted. Requires new information not presented at original hearing. Heard by full group meeting if council cannot reach agreement.

Evidence Standards

• Accusation alone is not evidence. Never punish based solely on one person's claim against another, regardless of the accuser's status.
• Physical evidence — highest weight. Document it: describe it in writing, state who found it, when, and who witnessed the discovery.
• Multiple independent witnesses — high weight. "Independent" means people with no prior relationship or shared motive.
• Single witness — medium weight. Requires corroborating circumstantial evidence for serious charges.
• Character evidence — low weight. Prior bad behavior is relevant context, not proof. Prior good behavior does not exonerate.
• Confession — high weight only if voluntary and without coercion. Confessions made under duress are inadmissible.
• Burden of proof: The accuser bears the burden. The accused is presumed innocent until the council is convinced beyond reasonable doubt (for exile/severe punishment) or by preponderance of evidence (for lesser disputes).

Punishment Philosophy

Exile — When and How

• Trigger conditions: Second serious offense after warning; first-offense rape/sexual assault; premeditated murder; deliberate endangerment of the group (sabotage, revealing location to hostile parties).
• Procedure: Council vote — supermajority (2/3) required. Subject is informed of the decision, reasoning, and timeline. Given opportunity to respond to council (not to change the decision, but to ensure process fairness).
• Execution: 24-hour preparation period; escorted to defined perimeter boundary; provided minimum humanitarian supplies (water for 24 hours, basic clothing appropriate to weather) unless a capital offense makes this politically impossible to maintain group morale.
• Record: Document the exile in the community record with full case file. This prevents revisionist history and provides evidence if the individual later returns claiming injustice.

7. Property Rights

The Spectrum

Pure communism (everything shared equally) and pure individualism (each person owns all they hold) both fail under stress. Historical successful communities use a hybrid:

Land Dispute Prevention

Land becomes contentious when stakes become high. Prevent disputes by establishing clear rules early:

1. Survey and map the land within the community's area of operation as early as possible.
2. Assign cultivation zones in the community register with names of responsible cultivators and date assigned.
3. Establish the rule: uncultivated land can be claimed by any member who commits to working it; land actively cultivated cannot be reassigned without council agreement and compensation.
4. Review land assignments annually. Abandoned plots revert to community allocation.

8. Trade & Economics

What Actually Holds Value Post-Collapse

The common belief is that gold and silver become the currency of collapse. This is true eventually but not immediately. The actual value hierarchy in the first months:

Common Units of Exchange — Historical

• Salt: Historically one of the most important trade goods. Preserves food, essential mineral, compact. Highly recommended for stockpiling as trade good.
• Grain (measured): Most ancient economies used a standardized bushel of grain as the base unit. Simple, universal need, and difficult to fake.
• Labor hours: Time banking — explicit exchange of hours of work. Eliminates need for a commodity currency entirely. LETS (Local Exchange Trading System) is a modern adaptation.
• Alcohol: Historically called "liquid currency." Compact, stable, universally valued, and produces more of itself.
• Ammunition: Extremely valuable in an armed society, but creates dangerous incentives — people with surplus ammunition have coercive power. Approach with caution.
• Precious metals: Long-term store of value once basic production systems are reestablished. Silver more practical than gold for small transactions (lower denomination).

Barter System Design

1. Establish a reference table — set approximate exchange ratios for common goods. 1 day of labor = X lbs of grain = Y doses of medication. Post it publicly. Update monthly based on supply/demand reality. This prevents exploitation of the uninformed.
2. Market day — designate a specific time (weekly is common) and neutral location for inter-group and internal trading. Advance announcement allows people to prepare what they'll offer and what they need. Creates information market efficiency.
3. Witness and record trades — significant trades (above a minimum threshold) should have a third-party witness and be recorded in the trade ledger. Prevents later "I never agreed to that" disputes.
4. Credit system — allow deferred trades, recorded in ledger. "I'll give you 5 lbs of flour now; you'll give me 2 hrs of carpentry work next week." Requires trust and record-keeping but dramatically increases trade volume and community cooperation.
5. Community fee — consider a small community fee (5–10% in goods) on all significant external trades. Funds community infrastructure projects and creates shared stake in market success.

Trade With Outside Groups

• Neutral ground: Trade meetings should occur outside both groups' perimeters when possible. Designate a known neutral location.
• Party size: Equal delegations; your security knows where you are and when to expect you back. Someone not in the trading party is monitoring.
• Escrow concept: For high-value trades with new partners, use a trusted third party holding goods from both sides until both confirm satisfaction. Prevents fraud.
• Information control: Do not reveal your group's size, exact location, or resource levels during trade negotiations. "We can trade X regularly" — not "we have a thousand pounds of it."
• Reciprocal good faith: Long-term trading relationships are more valuable than any single transaction. Don't cheat; don't let your traders cheat.

Preventing Hoarding & Black Markets

• Acceptable private reserve: Explicitly define and communicate what private storage is permitted. People hoard when they fear arbitrary confiscation. If they know the rule is "you may keep up to 7 days of personal food in your quarters," they are less likely to hoard secretly.
• Address root causes: Black markets form when official allocation is perceived as unfair or insufficient. If people are sneaking food, the official ration may be inadequate or the distribution may be inequitable.
• No-punishment reporting: Someone who reports a hoard they discover (rather than taking from it themselves) should be protected from retaliation. Reward the reporting, not the raiding.
• Occasional voluntary stocktake: Not a punitive inspection, but a community-wide "let's count everything" exercise once a month. Transparency reduces the social conditions that breed secret-keeping.

9. Integrating Outsiders

The Moral and Practical Framework

There is no ethically clean answer to the refugee question. Both "turn everyone away" and "admit everyone" lead to bad outcomes. The framework that works:

Assessment Protocol for Newcomers

Children and Orphans

Establish an explicit policy before you need it:

Recommended: Unaccompanied children under age 14 receive automatic provisional admission for humanitarian reasons. The community takes collective responsibility. Assign them to an existing family unit or create a designated care structure. Children represent long-term investment — they are a workforce and next-generation community core within 5–10 years. Any community that leaves children to die outside its perimeter has made a choice about what kind of community it is.

Children with parents follow the parents' admission status. Admission of parents with children is not leverage — do not separate children from parents as a negotiating tactic.

Cultural Integration

• Integrate people into existing work structures from day one — shared work creates community faster than shared meals.
• Explicitly state the community rules and have new members acknowledge them — not as a punishment, but as a welcome orientation.
• Assign existing members as integration mentors (not guards) to new members during probation.
• Do not expect cultural homogeneity. Different backgrounds are assets; different values about community rules are problems. Distinguish between them.

10. Record Keeping

Why Written Records Matter

Human memory fails under stress, rationalizes self-interest, and diverges over time. Written records prevent: revisionist history; property disputes; medication dosing errors; distribution disputes; and the gradual erosion of agreed-upon rules. Without records, groups drift and fracture. Assign a record keeper as a formal role.

Archival Methods

• Paper: Use acid-free paper if available (will last 50–200 years vs. 5–30 for regular paper). Write in pencil or permanent ink — ballpoint pen degrades in 20 years.
• Storage: Keep records in airtight container (Ziploc or sealed tin) away from moisture and light. Silica gel desiccant extends life significantly.
• Multiple copies: Critical records (charter, membership list, land registry, food inventory) should have at least 2 copies in different physical locations.
• Handwriting clarity: Write legibly. Documents will be read by people who don't know your handwriting.
• Dating: Date every entry. If you've lost track of the calendar, create a community reference: "Day 1 = the day [event] occurred" and count from there.

Required Registers

• Membership register: Full name, date of admission, skills, physical description, any conditions of admission.
• Supply inventory: Weekly count of all food stores, medical supplies, fuel, tools. Columns: item, quantity, unit, daily consumption rate, estimated days remaining.
• Decision log: Date, decision made, who proposed, vote (Y/N/abstain per council member), and brief reasoning. This prevents "that was never actually decided" arguments.
• Land registry: Plot description, assigned cultivator, date assigned, crop plan, any improvements made.
• Trade ledger: Date, parties, items exchanged, witnesses, fulfilled/pending.
• Incident log: Date, incident description, parties involved, resolution, any follow-up required. Medical incidents, security incidents, disputes.
• Death register: Name, age, date, cause if known, witnesses, location of burial.
• Annual census: Full head count with age, sex, skill summary, health status. Conduct every spring.

11. Printable Templates

Print this page or save offline. Templates designed for paper reproduction.